Method Body Wash Lawsuit: What the 'Non-Toxic' Case Really Was
The Method lawsuit TikTok rediscovered is a 2020 class action over the word 'non-toxic' on Method products. SC Johnson settled it for $2.25 million in 2021 - up to $10 per household - and agreed to stop labeling the covered products non-toxic. The claim window closed November 1, 2021. Here is the record, and what the videos get wrong.
Editorially Reviewed — Content reviewed for accuracy using published legal research, government data, and verified court records. See our methodology
Reviewed by Leonard Goldberg, Editor · Last updated
What the Lawsuit Alleged
Consumers alleged SC Johnson - Method's parent - labeled Method cleaning and personal-care products 'non-toxic' while they contained ingredients capable of harming people, pets or the environment (irritants and allergens among them). The claim was marketing deception, not injury: buyers said they paid a premium for a safety promise the ingredient lists didn't back. SC Johnson denied wrongdoing and settled.
Case Details
Consolidated consumer class action against S.C. Johnson & Son, Inc. over 'non-toxic'-labeled Method products; nationwide settlement administered at householdproductssettlement.com (now wound down). Class period: May 14, 2016 - May 13, 2021.
Status: Settled and Closed Since 2021
Who Was Eligible - and Who Isn't Now
U.S. purchasers of 'non-toxic'-labeled Method products between May 14, 2016 and May 13, 2021 could file by November 1, 2021 - attestation-based, no receipts needed for the base payment. Nobody can file today; the administrator site is gone, and any current 'Method claim' page is not connected to the case. The settlement covered marketing claims only - it neither found nor compensated any injury.
What the Case Did and Didn't Establish
Method Case Timeline
- 1
2020 — Class Action Filed
California consumers challenge 'non-toxic' labels on Method products.
- 2
2021 — $2.25M Settlement Approved
Up to $10 per household; SC Johnson agrees to drop 'non-toxic' from covered products.
- 3
November 1, 2021 — Claim Deadline
Filing closes; payments distribute; the site later winds down.
- 4
2025-2026 — TikTok Rediscovery
Label-change videos revive the story as a 'new' body-wash lawsuit; no new case exists.
Watch Out For
Old settlements make evergreen misinformation:
'Method settlement 2026' claim pages
The only Method settlement closed in 2021. Sites taking claims now are harvesting data.
'Method is toxic' videos
The settlement was about marketing language, with no safety finding by any court or regulator. The products were never recalled.
Body-wash brand confusion
Real body-wash/benzene issues involved OTHER brands' aerosols (2021-22 recalls). Method body wash was not recalled.
Method Lawsuit - FAQ
Is there a Method body wash lawsuit in 2026?
No new case exists. The 2020 'non-toxic' class action settled for $2.25M and closed to claims on November 1, 2021.
How much did the Method settlement pay?
Up to $10 per household without receipts, from the $2.25M fund - paid out after 2021 approval.
Why doesn't Method say 'non-toxic' anymore?
The settlement's injunctive term: SC Johnson agreed to stop using the claim on covered products. That label change - not a safety event - is what videos keep 'discovering'.
Is Method body wash safe?
No recall or regulatory action has ever targeted it. The lawsuit made no safety findings; ingredient sensitivities vary by person - the ingredient list, not a settled marketing case, is the relevant document.
Was Method part of the benzene recalls?
No - those covered aerosol sprays from P&G and Unilever brands. Method was sued over the word 'non-toxic', not contamination.
Can I still get the $10?
No. The deadline passed November 1, 2021; late claims were never accepted and the administrator has wound down.
Does SC Johnson face similar cases?
'Non-toxic' and 'natural' labeling suits have hit many CPG companies - including a parallel Windex case - most ending in similar label-change settlements. None is open for Method claims.
Separate from this case: were you injured in the last 2 years?
Class-action payouts are fixed amounts through an administrator. A personal injury claim is a different case — and often worth far more. Free estimate, no obligation.