What's the average settlement for a personal injury case?
Averages mislead because the distribution is bimodal — most cases are small, a few are huge. The median car-accident settlement is around $24,000 based on our analysis of 51,932 cases. But minor soft-tissue cases settle for $5K–$15K, surgical cases for $75K–$300K, and catastrophic injuries run to seven or eight figures. Use the valuation guide for your specific case.
Do I pay taxes on a personal injury settlement?
Generally no for physical injury settlements (IRC §104(a)(2)). Compensation for physical injuries, related medical expenses, and emotional distress arising from physical injury is tax-free. Taxable exceptions: punitive damages (always taxable), interest on settlements, lost-wage portions if you previously deducted medical expenses, and emotional-distress damages without a physical-injury origin. Confirm with a CPA — the split matters.
Should I accept the insurance company's first offer?
Almost never. First offers run 30–50% of fair value. The adjuster's software is calibrated assuming you'll counter. The Insurance Research Council reports attorney-represented PI claims settle for 3.5× higher on average than unrepresented ones. Counter with a documented number — not a feeling.
What counts as damages?
Two buckets: economic (medical bills, future care, lost wages, lost earning capacity, property damage, out-of-pocket costs — all receipt-backed) and non-economic (pain & suffering, loss of consortium, disfigurement, loss of enjoyment of life). Some cases also have punitive damages for egregious conduct. Most state caps apply only to non-economic damages.
What if the at-fault driver has minimum insurance?
Three paths: (1) UIM — your own underinsured motorist coverage picks up the gap if you have it. (2) Multiple defendants — drag in additional parties (employer if commercial, vehicle owner if different from driver, bar/restaurant if alcohol involved under dram-shop laws). (3) Personal assets — rarely productive but possible if defendant has substantial non-exempt assets. The reality: many bad cases stop at the policy limit.