“I Have a Structured Settlement and I Need Cash Now” — What Selling Actually Costs
A buyer does not pay you what your payments are worth — it pays their discounted present value, typically 9 to 14 percent a year less. A judge must approve the sale, and roughly one in ten filings does not get through. Here is how the numbers and the process really work. If you are searching because you need cash now, read the discount rate section before you call anyone — that number, not the advertised payout, is the price.
Editorially Reviewed — Content reviewed for accuracy using published legal research, government data, and verified court records. See our methodology
Reviewed by Leonard Goldberg, Editor · Last updated
What You Are Actually Selling
A structured settlement pays you a fixed schedule over years or decades, usually funded by an annuity. Selling means transferring some or all of those future payments to a buyer — a factoring company — in exchange for a lump sum today.
The lump sum is always smaller than the total you give up, and often dramatically so. The gap is the discount rate: the buyer's compensation for time, inflation and profit. On a long payment stream, a few percentage points a year compound into a very large difference between what you receive and what you surrender.
This is not inherently a bad deal. It is a deal whose price is easy to misjudge, because the cost is expressed as a rate while the loss is felt as a total.
Case Details
49 states and the District of Columbia have a Structured Settlement Protection Act requiring a judge to approve any transfer before it is effective. The federal tax rule at 26 U.S.C. § 5891 reinforces this: a transfer that does not follow the state act and obtain court approval loses its favourable tax treatment. In practice, no legitimate buyer will complete a purchase without a court order.
The Numbers
Those figures come from within the industry — comparison sites operated in the secondary market — rather than from an official statistics source. Use them as a negotiating benchmark, not as a published standard.
For context on how far this can drift: filings submitted to the federal consumer protection bureau have documented rates of 16 to 28 percent, in some cases exceeding what the relevant state's usury limits would allow on a loan. That range is the reason getting more than one offer matters more here than in almost any other financial transaction.
What the Judge Actually Checks
Court approval is not a formality, but it is also not a high bar. Industry sources report an approval rate of 85 to 92 percent for properly filed transfers, with denials under 5 percent — again, industry figures rather than court statistics.
The legal standard is your best interest, taking into account your welfare and any dependants. In practice, judges deny transfers for a recognisable set of reasons: the seller has no other income and would end up dependent on public assistance; the stated reason for selling does not justify surrendering long-term income; or the required disclosures were not properly made.
State acts also require written disclosure of the financial terms before you commit, a waiting period, and the right to independent professional advice — mandatory in some states, waivable in others. Expect the court process itself to take up to about 90 days.
How to Judge an Offer
Ask for the total of the payments you are giving up and the effective annual rate in writing. State acts require the terms to be disclosed; a reluctance to put the rate on paper tells you something on its own.
Get multiple offers. Given a documented spread from single digits to the high twenties, competing quotes are the single most effective thing you can do — worth far more than any negotiating technique.
Consider selling only part. Most transfers can cover a portion of the payment stream or a defined window of years. If you need a specific sum for a specific purpose, selling exactly that much preserves the rest of the income.
How the Process Runs
- 1
You request quotes
Approach several buyers with the same information: payment amounts, dates and the total stream. Ask each for the discount rate, not only the lump sum.
- 2
Written disclosure of terms
Before you commit, the state act requires the financial terms in writing — the lump sum, the payments transferred, their total, and the effective rate.
- 3
Waiting period and independent advice
State acts build in a waiting period and a right to independent professional advice. In some states that advice is mandatory; in others it can be waived. Taking it is almost always worth the cost.
- 4
The transfer petition is filed
The buyer files with the court. The annuity issuer and other interested parties are notified and may object.
- 5
The best-interest hearing
A judge examines whether the transfer serves your best interest and that of any dependants, including why you are selling and what income you will have left.
- 6
Order and funding — allow about 90 days
With approval, the transfer becomes effective and the buyer funds it. Without an order, the transfer is not valid and loses its federal tax treatment under § 5891.
Where This Goes Wrong
The regulatory record in this industry centres on one thing: steering people away from genuinely independent advice.
"Independent" advice the buyer arranges
The federal consumer protection bureau brought an action against a factoring company, its chief executive and chief operating officer, alleging they steered consumers — targeting recipients of lead-paint injury settlements — to an adviser the company itself paid, while downplaying how significant the transaction was. It ended in a judgment with disgorgement, a penalty and a permanent ban on that conduct. That case ran from 2016 to 2021; we found no more recent enforcement action, so treat it as a documented pattern rather than a current alert. If a buyer offers to arrange your adviser, choose your own.
A lump sum quoted with no rate
Without the discount rate you cannot compare offers or judge whether one is reasonable. Any buyer unwilling to state it in writing is not a buyer to work with.
Pressure to sell everything at once
Selling the entire stream maximises the buyer's return and your loss. Partial transfers exist precisely so you can raise a specific amount without giving up the rest — and a court is more likely to approve a transfer with a clear, limited purpose.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much will I actually get?
Less than the total of the payments you give up — the difference is the discount rate, typically 9 to 14 percent a year in 2026 and up to about 18 percent across the market. Larger streams above roughly $200,000 have been quoted at 7 to 12 percent. These are industry figures, so treat them as benchmarks for negotiation.
Do I need a judge's approval?
Yes. 49 states and the District of Columbia require it under their Structured Settlement Protection Act, and 26 U.S.C. § 5891 ties the federal tax treatment to following that process. A transfer without a court order is not valid.
How likely is approval, and how long does it take?
Industry sources report 85 to 92 percent approval for properly filed transfers, with denials under 5 percent, and a court process of up to about 90 days. Those are industry numbers, not court statistics.
Why would a judge say no?
The recurring reasons: the seller has no other income and would become dependent on public assistance; the reason for selling does not justify giving up long-term income; or the required disclosures were not properly made. The standard is your best interest and that of your dependants.
Can I sell only part of my payments?
Usually yes — a portion of each payment, or a defined window of years. If you need a specific amount for a specific purpose, selling exactly that much keeps the remaining income intact and tends to present better to a court.
Is the lump sum taxable?
Where the original settlement was tax-free for personal physical injury, a properly approved transfer under the state act and § 5891 generally does not change that character. Because the answer depends on your specific settlement and how the transfer is structured, confirm it with a CPA rather than assuming.
What is the single most useful thing I can do?
Get several written offers and compare the discount rates, not the lump sums. Documented rates range from single digits to the high twenties for what is essentially the same transaction — no negotiating tactic moves the number as much as competition does.
Separate from this case: were you injured in the last 2 years?
Class-action payouts are fixed amounts through an administrator. A personal injury claim is a different case — and often worth far more. Free estimate, no obligation.