Long Term Disability Lawyer: Why the Appeal Matters More Than the Lawsuit
Long-term disability is not Social Security disability, and the difference is not academic. If your policy came through your employer, ERISA governs it — and under ERISA you generally get 180 days to appeal a denial, after which a court will decide your case on the file as it stood at that moment.
Editorially Reviewed — Content reviewed for accuracy using published legal research, government data, and verified court records. See our methodology
Reviewed by Leonard Goldberg, Editor · Last updated
LTD Is Not SSDI, and Most People Conflate Them
Social Security disability is a federal benefit you qualify for through work credits, decided by the Social Security Administration, with a defined appeal ladder ending before an administrative law judge. Long-term disability is a private insurance policy, usually provided through your employer, that pays a percentage of your income — commonly 50-70% — when you cannot work. They have different definitions of disability, different decision-makers and completely different appeal procedures, and you can be approved for one and denied the other without contradiction. The definition matters most: many LTD policies pay for the first 24 months if you cannot perform your own occupation, then switch to a far stricter any occupation standard. A large share of terminations happen exactly at that 24-month mark, and it catches people who assumed an approved claim was settled.
Case Details
If the policy came through your employer, it is almost certainly governed by ERISA, the federal law covering employee benefit plans, and that changes everything about how a dispute proceeds. Under ERISA there is no jury, damages are generally limited to the benefits owed rather than punitive damages for bad faith, and you must exhaust the plan's internal appeal before you can sue at all. Policies bought individually, and plans from government or church employers, are typically outside ERISA and follow state insurance law — which often does allow bad-faith damages and a jury. Which category you are in is the first thing to establish, and it is determined by how the policy was obtained, not by the insurer's name.
The 180 Days, and What They Are Actually For
What a Denial Letter Must Tell You
An ERISA denial is required to give a specific explanation rather than a conclusion. It must identify the plan provisions the decision relied on, tell you that you may obtain a copy of the administrative record free of charge, and explain your appeal rights and deadlines. That right to the record is the most underused entitlement in this area: the file will contain the insurer's internal reviewer reports, any paper-only medical review, surveillance if it was conducted, and the vocational analysis behind an “any occupation” determination. Request it immediately, because you cannot rebut reasoning you have not read, and every day spent waiting is taken out of the same 180 days you need for building the response.
What Is Actually at Stake
The Sequence That Decides the Case
- 1
The denial or termination letter arrives
Note the date — the 180 days run from it. Read what the insurer says it relied on, because that is what the appeal has to answer. A termination after benefits have been paid for two years usually signals the switch to the 'any occupation' standard.
- 2
Request the administrative record
You are entitled to it free of charge. It reveals the internal reviews, any file-only medical opinion, surveillance and vocational reports. Do this first, not last — the clock is already running.
- 3
Build the file
The heart of the matter. Treating physician opinions written to the policy's definition, functional capacity evaluation, objective testing, vocational evidence, and answers to the specific criticisms in the denial. What is not filed here generally cannot be used later.
- 4
Submit the appeal within 180 days
Complete rather than early. An appeal filed quickly but thinly closes the record on a weak file, and that file is what a court will eventually read.
- 5
The plan decides within 45 days
Extendable once by a further 45 days for special circumstances. If the plan blows its own deadlines, that failure can affect the standard of review a court applies — which is one of the few procedural advantages available to claimants.
- 6
Suit under ERISA § 502(a)
Filed in federal court after the appeal is exhausted. No jury, decided on the administrative record, with the standard of review depending on whether the plan granted itself discretionary authority. Remedy is generally the benefits owed, not damages.
Where Claims Are Lost
Most denied LTD claims are not lost at trial. They are lost during the appeal window, in four recognisable ways:
Appealing without adding evidence
A letter disagreeing with the denial, unaccompanied by new medical and vocational evidence, closes the record on the same file the insurer already rejected. The appeal is not a request to reconsider — it is the last chance to change what is in the file.
Assuming you can add proof later in court
Under ERISA you generally cannot. The strongest expert report in the world is worth nothing if it was obtained after the administrative appeal closed. This single rule accounts for more lost cases than any other.
Social media and surveillance
Insurers conduct surveillance and review public social media in contested claims. A photograph of one good day, without context, becomes an exhibit — and it will be in the administrative record that the court reads.
Questions People Actually Ask
How long do I have to appeal a long term disability denial?
Under ERISA, generally at least 180 days from the denial. Missing it usually forfeits both the appeal and the right to sue, because ERISA requires you to exhaust the plan's internal process first. Individual policies outside ERISA follow state law and different timeframes.
Can I just sue the insurance company?
Not until the internal appeal is exhausted, if ERISA governs your policy. And when you do sue, there is no jury and the court decides on the administrative record rather than hearing new evidence. Policies bought individually, or through government and church employers, are usually outside ERISA and follow state law, which can allow a jury and bad-faith damages.
Why were my benefits stopped after two years?
Most likely the definition changed. Many policies pay for 24 months if you cannot perform your own occupation, then require that you cannot perform any occupation for which you are reasonably qualified. Terminations cluster at that mark, and they are appealable on the same 180-day timeline as an initial denial.
Is long term disability the same as SSDI?
No. LTD is private insurance, usually through your employer; SSDI is a federal benefit based on work credits. They use different definitions and separate processes, so approval or denial of one does not determine the other. Most LTD policies also offset SSDI payments, which is why insurers require you to apply for it.
Should I accept a lump-sum buyout?
It depends on numbers worth calculating first: the monthly benefit times the months to your maximum benefit age, discounted to present value. Offers are reduced for that discounting and for the insurer's estimate of the risk that benefits would end anyway. A buyout is final, so the offer should be compared against the full remaining value rather than against nothing.
What does an ERISA disability lawyer cost?
Typically a contingency fee around a third of the benefits recovered, including past-due benefits, with no upfront payment. ERISA also permits a court to award attorney's fees against the plan in some circumstances. Ask how future monthly benefits are treated in the fee agreement — practice varies.
What if my employer is a government or church body?
Government and church plans are generally exempt from ERISA, as are policies you bought yourself. That usually means state insurance law applies: a jury may be available, bad-faith damages may be recoverable, and evidence is not confined to an administrative record. Establishing which regime applies is the first step, because it changes every deadline that follows.
Is a disability insurance lawyer the same as a disability lawyer?
They are usually different jobs, and picking the wrong one wastes months. A disability insurance lawyer fights a private insurer over a policy — typically employer-provided long-term disability governed by ERISA, or an individual policy you bought yourself. The opponent is a company, the record is built during an internal appeal, and in ERISA cases a court will often review only the evidence already in that administrative record. A Social Security disability lawyer deals with a federal benefits agency, different deadlines and a fee capped by statute. If your income stopped and an insurer denied the claim, you want the first. If you are applying for or appealing SSDI or SSI, you want the second. Some people need both at once, because private policies frequently offset against Social Security benefits.
Separate from this case: were you injured in the last 2 years?
Class-action payouts are fixed amounts through an administrator. A personal injury claim is a different case — and often worth far more. Free estimate, no obligation.