Instacart Lawsuit: $60 Million FTC Refunds, AI Price Tests and Shopper Pay
Questions about this case?
AI Legal Assistant · free · answers in seconds · general information, not legal advice
The money people are asking about comes from the Federal Trade Commission, not from an Instacart class action. A federal judge entered the FTC's $60 million order on January 13, 2026, and the refunds are meant for people charged for Instacart+ without their express informed consent. As of September 30, 2026, the FTC has not opened a refund program for it: no payment date, no administrator, no claim form. Separately, Instacart ended its AI price tests on December 22, 2025; the investigations that followed have produced no settlement or fund we could find.
Editorially Reviewed — Content reviewed for accuracy using published legal research, government data, and verified court records. See our methodology
Reviewed by Leonard Goldberg, Editor · Last updated
What the FTC Said Instacart Did
The FTC's complaint, filed December 18, 2025, makes three main allegations.
“Free delivery” that was not free. Instacart advertised free delivery on first orders — often the first three — while still charging a mandatory “service fee.” Per the complaint, that fee adds at least 7.5% to 15% to the order, is not charged on pickup orders, and only shows up at checkout.
A “100% satisfaction guarantee” that mostly paid in credits. Customers with late or botched orders were typically offered a small credit toward a future order instead of a refund, and the complaint says the refund option was hidden from the self-service menu used to report problems.
Free trials that turned into paid memberships. Most people joined Instacart+ through 14-day free trials that automatically renewed into an annual plan, typically $99 per year, without a clear disclosure — while being told they could “cancel anytime.” The FTC alleges that hundreds of thousands of consumers paid membership fees without receiving benefits or refunds.
Instacart settled without admitting or denying the allegations.
Case Details
FTC v. Maplebear Inc., d/b/a Instacart, No. 4:25-cv-10783-JST, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California. The complaint and proposed settlement were filed December 18, 2025 after a 2-0 Commission vote. Judge Jon S. Tigar signed the stipulated order on January 13, 2026. It enters a $60,000,000 judgment, payable within 14 days, bars Instacart from misrepresenting delivery costs and refund guarantees, and requires express informed consent before subscription charges. Documents: FTC case page.
AI price tests — investigations, not lawsuits with a payout. According to Consumer Reports, Reuters reported on December 17, 2025 that the FTC had opened an investigation into Instacart's pricing technology (the FTC does not comment on investigations); the New York Attorney General wrote to Instacart on January 8, 2026 under the state's Algorithmic Pricing Disclosure Act; the California Attorney General opened a surveillance-pricing investigation in late January; and the U.S. House Oversight Committee requested documents from Instacart and other companies in March 2026.
Shopper pay — local matters. MyNorthwest reported on September 24, 2026 that Instacart is paying nearly $150,000 to 846 workers to resolve violations of Seattle's App-Based Worker Minimum Payment Ordinance, enforced by the city's Office of Labor Standards. In New York City, Instacart is the plaintiff: it challenged the city's grocery-delivery minimum pay, lost in district court and appealed to the Second Circuit, as described in a June 6, 2026 Reason commentary.
Investors. A securities class action announced by a plaintiffs' firm in February 2024 concerns people who bought Instacart (Maplebear) stock in or after its IPO of about September 19, 2023. It is not a customer case, and we could not confirm its current status.
Canada. Consumer Law Group filed a proposed class action on February 12, 2025 for Instacart.ca customers outside Quebec, alleging fees were added after the advertised price. It does not cover U.S. customers.
Status: Order Entered, Refunds Not Yet Announced
AI price tests — ended, under investigation. Instacart stopped item price tests on December 22, 2025; retailers may still test promotions and discounts. We found no settlement, fund or claim form tied to the price tests.
Shoppers — Seattle resolved, New York contested. Instacart says it paid the affected Seattle shoppers in full. Instacart's challenge to New York City's minimum pay was on appeal as of June 2026.
Class actions. We found no open Instacart class action settlement with a claim form as of September 30, 2026. Our open class action settlements list shows the cases you can still file in.
Follow this case
There's no claim deadline yet. We'll email you if a settlement opens a claim period.
Who Can Expect an FTC Refund
The FTC's announcement names one group: people charged for Instacart+ without their express informed consent — in the complaint's account, typically a 14-day free trial that rolled into a paid annual membership. The FTC has not published exact criteria, a date range or amounts. The order requires Instacart to hand over customer information for the refunds within 14 days of a written FTC request.
The practical test is your statement history. Look for an Instacart+ charge (typically $99) right after a free trial you never meant to keep, especially if you never used the membership. There is nothing to sign up for now; if the FTC needs claims, it says the instructions will appear at ftc.gov/refunds.
People who paid a service fee on a “free delivery” order, or got credits instead of refunds, are part of the FTC's allegations — but the announcement names only Instacart+ charges as the refund group. Whether anyone else is included has not been announced.
How Much Money There Is
Timing. The FTC says it cannot pay until it has both the money and the customer data, and aims to pay within 6 months after that. For comparison, its Grubhub order was entered at the end of 2024 and those refunds went out in August 2026 — see our Grubhub lawsuit page.
Beyond the FTC order, we found no settlement, no fund and no claim form — including for the AI price tests.
Instacart Lawsuit Timeline
- 1
December 9, 2025 — The Price-Test Investigation
Consumer Reports and Groundwork Collaborative publish tests with 437 volunteers: prices for the same item differed by up to 23 percent from one customer to the next, and identical carts differed by about 7 percent on average.
- 2
December 18, 2025 — FTC Sues and Settles the Same Day
The FTC files its complaint over “free delivery,” the satisfaction guarantee and Instacart+ trials, together with a proposed $60 million order. A separate FTC pricing probe had been reported the day before.
- 3
December 22, 2025 — Instacart Ends Item Price Tests
Instacart says it will immediately stop retailers' price experiments on its platform. Wegmans says it had already stopped using the software on December 10.
- 4
January 13, 2026 — Judge Enters the $60 Million Order
Judge Jon S. Tigar signs the stipulated order in the Northern District of California. Payment to the FTC is due within 14 days.
- 5
January to March 2026 — State and Congressional Probes
New York's Attorney General writes to Instacart on January 8 about its pricing disclosures; California opens a surveillance-pricing investigation; the House Oversight Committee requests documents in March.
- 6
September 2026 — Seattle Back Pay, No FTC Refunds Yet
On September 24, a nearly $150,000 settlement for 846 Seattle shoppers is reported. As of September 30, the FTC still lists no Instacart refund program.
Three Instacart Refund Traps
A famous brand, $60 million and no official claim page yet — that gap is what imposters use:
“File your Instacart FTC refund claim” sites
No Instacart claim form has been announced as of September 30, 2026. If one is ever needed, the FTC lists the program at ftc.gov/refunds with the administrator's name and phone number. The FTC never charges a fee and never asks for your Social Security or bank account number.
Emails saying a PayPal refund is waiting
The FTC does send some refunds through PayPal, but it emails you first from an address ending in .gov. A message from any other domain asking you to log in or “confirm” a card to release an Instacart refund is phishing.
“Instacart's AI pricing overcharged you — claim your share”
We found no settlement or fund for the price tests. A page that asks for your Instacart login or card number to “calculate your overcharge” is collecting account data, not filing anything.
Instacart Lawsuit — Questions People Ask
Is there an Instacart class action I can join?
Not one with money to claim, as far as we found on September 30, 2026. The $60 million comes from the FTC's own lawsuit, which has no class members and nothing to opt into. If you qualify, the FTC typically pays from Instacart's customer records or posts claim instructions at ftc.gov/refunds.
When will I get my Instacart refund from the FTC?
No date has been announced. The order was entered January 13, 2026, and the FTC aims to pay within 6 months of having both the money and the customer data it needs — but as of September 30, 2026, no Instacart refund program is listed. Watch ftc.gov/refunds rather than third-party sites.
Do I need to file a claim for the $60 million settlement?
Probably not, though the FTC has not announced it yet. The FTC says most of its cases need no claim because the company must supply a customer list; it asks for claims only when data is missing. Instacart must provide that information within 14 days of a written FTC request.
Who is covered by the Instacart refunds?
The FTC names people charged for Instacart+ without their express informed consent — typically after a 14-day free trial rolled into a paid membership, usually $99 a year. It has not published exact criteria or amounts.
Did Instacart charge different people different prices?
A Consumer Reports and Groundwork Collaborative investigation published December 9, 2025 found per-item differences of up to 23 percent for the same product, in price experiments run on Instacart at retailers including Costco, Kroger, Safeway and Target. Instacart ended item price tests on December 22, 2025. Regulators are investigating; we found no settlement or refund for it.
I shop for Instacart. Is there a case for me?
The shopper matters we could confirm are local. In Seattle, 846 workers are covered by a settlement of nearly $150,000 after two restaurants near the Shoreline border were mistakenly treated as outside city limits; Instacart says it paid them in full. In New York City, Instacart itself sued over the city's grocery-delivery minimum pay and, per a June 2026 commentary, appealed after losing in district court. For other delivery-app payouts, see our DoorDash settlement tracker and the Uber Eats priority fee lawsuit.
Is an email about an Instacart refund real?
Check three things: the program is listed at ftc.gov/refunds, any email from the FTC itself comes from an address ending in .gov, and nobody asks you for money, a Social Security number or a bank login. As of September 30, 2026 no Instacart refund program is listed, so a message saying your refund is ready deserves suspicion.
What should I do right now?
Check your card statements for Instacart+ charges you did not expect, keep the email address on your Instacart account current, and cancel any trial you do not want before it renews. If an order goes wrong, ask for a refund to your payment method rather than accepting a credit by default — the FTC order bars Instacart from misrepresenting whether refunds are available.
Separate from this case: were you injured in the last 2 years?
Class-action payouts are fixed amounts through an administrator. A personal injury claim is a different case — and often worth far more. Free estimate, no obligation.
Related Consumer Brand Lawsuits
Grubhub Lawsuit & FTC Refunds
FTC checks and PayPal payments went out in August 2026
DoorDash Settlement Check
Which DoorDash payouts are real, and which deadlines passed
Uber Eats Priority Fee Lawsuit
A delivery-fee class action with no settlement yet
Open Class Action Settlements
Settlements you can still file a claim in